Fashion Face Off: Who Wore It Best

Two style profiles. One great dress. Sometimes the same dress makes a different statement on someone else. Check out this gallery of stars who rocked the same frock, but differently.

Posted in: Fashion

In this slideshow: Heidi Klum, Hilary Rhoda, Iman, Chanel Iman, Arlenis Sosa, Bar Refaeli, Alexandra Richards

Embed slideshow

It's obvious models Arlenis Sosa and Alexandra Richards have a thing for Alexander Wang. Both girls wore the designer's black and blue curve-hugging dress out on the town. With slicked-back hair and the addition of a black blazer, Arlenis wears it Contemporary Chic. Rule Breaker Alexandra, on the other hand, opted for tousled hair, oversize hoop earrings, and a red pouch purse. How would you wear the dress?

Supermodel Bar Refaeli and Oscar winner Halle Berry both chose a gorgeous golden Elie Saab gown for red carpet events. Bar let her Modern Boho tendencies shine through with bold turquoise jewelry, while Classic Sophisticate Halle kept things simple with gold bangles and earrings. Both look stunning. How would you accessorize the gown?

Model turned fashion designer Kimora Lee Simmons wore this strapless, vibrant blue dress from her Baby Phat Spring 2008 collection after she debuted the collection at Fashion Week. She accessorized with a jeweled belt buckle, sky-high stilettos, and a stunning sapphire and diamond necklace. Kimora has never been one to follow the rules. Model Chanel Iman created a Modern Boho look with the dress by trading in the beaded belt for a chunky suede one, and instead of sandals she chose Christian Louboutin's For Ever Tina suede and fringe platform boots. Both are making the dress their own, but which model matches your style?

In February, Heidi Klum closed Season 6 of Project Runway in an eye-catching two-piece suit by Matthew Williamson. Letting the hot Schiaparelli pink ensemble shine, Heidi accessorized simply with a crystal broach and elegant slicked-back hair for a Contemporary Chic look. Five months later, Pixie Geldof took to the red carpet in the same suit for the Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince film premiere. Her Rule Breaker version included a black tunic with strands of silver jewelry, a chunky black bag, and peep-toe booties. She is the daughter of a rock star, after all. How far would you take this outfit?

Models Hilary Rhoda and Alexa Chung both wore the same blue Burberry lace dress to a party hosted by the fashion house. Thanks to their very distinct styles, the dress looks unique on each of them. Hilary's Classic Sophisticate approach to the dress included stylish Manolos and a thin belt. Alexa opted for an edgy, Contemporary Chic take on the sheath, wearing it with a menswear blazer, studded belt, and platform booties. So when it comes to this dress, are you a Hilary or an Alexa?

Supermodel Iman first wore this stunning violet Lanvin dress from the Spring 2008 collection to a Lanvin hosted event in October of 2007. Seven months later, actress Natalie Portman wore her version—sans tights and chandelier earrings—of the strapless number to the Blindness premiere at the Cannes Film Festival. Both opted for simple black pumps and pulled-back hair. How would you accessorize the dress?